The Dirty Secret of “Test Optional” Colleges

Today we’re diving into a hard truth about test-optional colleges. In recent years, many colleges have adopted test-optional admission policies. What does that mean? Simply put, you can apply without submitting SAT or ACT scores and still be considered for admission based on the strength of other elements in your application like your grades, academic rigor, essays, extracurricular activities, and anything else you provide. For students who aren’t great test-takers, deal with test anxiety, or whose scores don’t reflect their true academic ability (unlike their grades), taking advantage of test-optional policies might seem like the perfect path forward.

But here’s what so many students and parents overlook: while the college admissions process may be test-optional, the actual college classes at most universities are not. Let’s break this down and explore why this matters, plus what you can do about it.

The Reality of College-Level Testing

Once you’re enrolled in college, testing becomes unavoidable. You’ll face big exams like midterms and finals, and in some courses, those are the only things that determine your grade. Homework, projects, and class participation? They might not factor into your final mark at all; they’re often just tools to help you learn the material throughout the term.

If you’re genuinely a poor test-taker or struggle with test anxiety, this can be a rude awakening. The skills you avoided honing during admissions could come back to bite you when your academic success (and potentially your degree) depends on performing well under exam conditions.

Your Two Main Options

The good news? You have choices. If testing is a real barrier for you, consider these paths:

Option 1: Seek Out Test-Free Colleges

Do your research to find the (relatively small) list of colleges that don’t require tests in their classes. When you’re on college visits or chatting with reps at a local college fair, ask pointed questions like: “If I attend your school, are there classes I can take where I won’t have to sit for tests? I have test anxiety/am not a strong test-taker.” This can help you identify programs that align with your needs and evaluate students through alternative methods, like projects, papers, or portfolios.

Option 2: Become a Better Test-Taker

The more proactive route: put in the work to build those skills now. Learn effective strategies, practice under timed conditions, and develop the confidence to tackle tests head-on. By investing time in preparation, you’ll not only boost your chances in admissions (if you choose to submit scores) but also ensure you’re truly college-ready. When you arrive on campus, you’ll be equipped to ace those midterms and finals, earn the grades you deserve, and thrive academically.

Final Thoughts

The “dirty secret” of test-optional policies is that they don’t extend to the classroom: college life will demand testing skills one way or another. Don’t let this catch you off guard; start planning accordingly. If you have questions or need help building your test-taking prowess, reach out to us at Solution Prep. Give us a call at 732-556-8220, we’re here to help!

For more insights and resources, visit SolutionPrep.com. And check out the full video on our YouTube channel to hear it straight from me.